• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Website of Steve Neff

  • BLOG
  • SHOP
  • MEMBER’S AREA
    • JOIN
    • FAQ
    • MEMBER LOGIN
    • Member Monthly Lessons
  • RAVES
  • CONTACT
You are here: Home / Jazz Improvisation / Why is Learning Jazz Patterns Foreign to Me?

Why is Learning Jazz Patterns Foreign to Me?

August 24, 2015 by Steve 7 Comments

I received this question in an email the other day and I thought it would be good to try to answer it in detail on the blog here so others can benefit from it:

Question:

Steve,

I have always listened to jazz, but I tend to favor simpler, lyrical playing like Houston Person, Gene Ammons, etc., but I like Dex, Mintzer, and Brecker.   All my studies were aimed at classical (I call it “academic”).  I played lyrical jazz well, but I never attempted to play more complex stuff like Mintzer, Brecker, or you.  You once heard a sample of me and said I sounded very diatonic.  That’s true.  I know scales and intervals.  I tend to be very symmetric or linear.  If I play intervals, I play them in ascending or descending pattern using the same interval.  I hear something in your playing that I cannot put my finger on.  It’s like an interval up followed by a different interval down then 2-3 notes of a scale, maybe an approach note, then more dissimilar intervals in the other direction, etc.  Basically, the pattern never sits still or repeats sufficiently for me to hear what is going on.  And having worked only on academic etudes, concertos, and big band, I have no idea what you are playing.  I see jazz improvisation comments about chords.  I can play chord tones and arpeggios, but I don’t play chords on saxophone (I do that on guitar).  Therefore, I only use chords and key to open up the best candidate notes for the music.  Are your patterns (that do not sound like patterns) a way for you to play the chord?  If so, it sounds like much more than the chord.  On guitar I play 13ths and 11ths, but more than that tends to lose the gravity or real chord meaning.   I want to learn to do some of what you, Brecker, Mintzer are doing. 

Your YouTube of Green Dolphin Street (soprano) can serve for some examples.  

What are you doing at 2:22-2:23?  I had lots of ear training and music theory.  But these intervals and scales steps do not “ring a bell” with me. 

At 2:51-3:00 there is a good example because you are playing the pattern slowly.  My question is do you and guys that play these patterns “hear” this in your head or when you first began using this type of pattern were you mentally selecting something that you had been taught to play?  You see, I don’t find this type of note choice dissonant or in bad taste, but my ear hears more like a vocalists’ ear, and these notes are never in my head.

On your website in you soprano mouthpiece review of the Selmer Super Session “J” from 00:35-00:40 you have momentarily left the “middle eastern” sound and you play these note patterns that are ok with my ear’s “note police” but I don’t hear it and say “I know what he is doing. He’s playing maj 3rds” or “min 3rds” or “4ths” or “5ths”, etc.  What are you doing?

 So, I am asking three questions and #1-3 are similar.  First and third questions are what are those specific patterns.  Second question is about what you hear in your head versus what you play based on your mental breakdown of the music – you probably hear these notes now, but did you hear them as useful notes when you first learned  them?

Thank you

Response:

XXXXX, Thanks for the question, I hope I can answer it thoroughly and give you some answers that help in your journey.

In each of those examples that you ask about,  I am using concepts that have added to my jazz vocabulary over the years. I practiced these different concepts so much, that I can run them together and combine them in different ways when improvising.

Here is the Green Dolphin Street 2:22 example that you asked about:

https://cdn.neffmusic.com/2015/August/GDclip1.mp3

 

The first 5 notes BGABG are just a melodic shape I play a lot and practiced on chords in the past. If we put numbers to that shape you have 53453.   I cover patterns like these in my “New Ultimate II-V-I Primer” book.  There are hundreds of simple patterns in that book like this that are so important to get down and they start you off with a solid foundation you can pull ideas from.

The next 5 notes are an approach in E minor from my Approach Note Velocity book. GD#F#D#E.  I’m thinking E-7 here as that is the chord and then approaching the E of measure two.  The notes that have tension on them like D# are ok because they lead to the resolution on a chord tone on the downbeat which solidifies the tonality and resolves the line.  This is an important concept and I teach it in my Mastering the Bebop Scale books, Approach Note Velocity books, The New Ultimate II-V-I Primer book and many of my video and audio lessons.

After the E above, I just run up the F# diminished scale but starting on the E I just resolved to. This is a great scale to use on a dominant chord that is about to resolve down a 5th like the F#7(b9) is about to.  I end on a line in B-7 which is almost all chord tones. Interestingly enough, notice that on B-7 the first 5 notes are the same melodic pattern I started the line with 53453.  

Here is the 2:51 line you asked about:

https://cdn.neffmusic.com/2015/August/GDclip2.mp3

 

At the 2:51 mark I start the line based off of the minor ii-V going to E-7 in measure two. All I am doing is using approaches from my book in E minor to start the line and lead it to the E-7 of the second measure. Those approaches just happen to match perfectly with the F#-7 B7 chords.  The great thing about approach lines is that because they are moving in and out of a given tonality the can sound great over chord changes that are passing underneath the lines.  To check out this concept in action these lessons are great:

  • Approaching Rhythm Changes Lesson
  • Beautiful Love Approach Note Lesson
  • Autumn Leaves-Approach Note Velocity Combinations Lesson
  • and you can even check out my free lesson on Approach Notes on the site.

In measure two, I am just using the A7 bebop scale material from my “Mastering the Dominant Bebop Scale” book.   I start with a bebop link in A7  EBDBC# (You can use these over E-7 like I talk about in the book) then I head down the A bebop scale C#BAAbG and end with a resolution link from my bebop book based off of the A altered scale.

As you can see, it’s not as simple as “What are you doing?’ I’m combining different concepts and elements that I worked on for years.  In the above example I am using: approach note pattern, bebop pattern, altered scale pattern.

In the Super Session J soprano mouthpiece clip (click here to here the full clip)  at the :35 mark, that is simply me leaving the harmonic scale sound of the “middle eastern sound” (as you state in your question) and changing the line to a bebop sounding minor line in C minor.  I’m still thinking C harmonic minor but combined with approach note patterns.  I’m also forming the line in a more straight ahead context where I’m thinking more G7b9 to C minor.  So in this case the line is:  

https://cdn.neffmusic.com/2015/August/SSJclip.mp3

 

These are all short ideas from my Approach Note Velocity book that I have linked together to form this long line.

Do I hear all these things before hand and just play them? Yes and No.  I imagine them and think of them but most times they are part of my language and vocabulary.  When you speak, do you hear or imagine the word you are about to say before you say it?  To me,  it’s similar to speaking.  When I talk or type I think about what I want to say or communicate and then I choose from the words I know how to best communicate what I want to say.  So when I am playing, I try to think the same way.  I combine  musical words together to form phrases much like you link words together to form sentences when you speak.  

The key is really knowing these musical words.  If you don’t know a lot of words,  communicating is hard if not impossible.  I have practiced many musical words over the years over and over in all keys……probably almost as much as I have spoken words (maybe not, but I have practiced an awful lot) so the end result is that I can play with very little thought sometimes.  Many students tell me this is a foreign concept and impossible for them to do but I show them that this isn’t true.  While talking to them,  I ask them how many of the individual words they thought of in the last sentence they just said.  Usually the answer is none.  They just thought of what they wanted to say and then started speaking and they found the words. Everyone does it while speaking every day! That is improvising!

So if we can do it while speaking and using words,  why do we have such a hard time with musical sentences?  The key is learning musical ideas in smaller groupings much like words I think.  In my Mastering the Bebop Scale books and Approach Note Velocity books I divide the ideas up into 2-8 note musical words.  The power of this is that you can combine these musical words any way you like just like when using words when speaking.  This is where the improvisation part comes in and makes it more interesting.  Instead of learning a 4 measure lick that I can play only one way, I prefer to learn the lick by dividing it up into shorter musical words that I then can combine in a hundred different ways depending on what I think of or imagine.  

When I was a kid and even in college I was  taught that the key to bebop was memorizing these long licks and lines.  I spent hours and hours learning 4 measure lines like I have in my “The Best II-V-I Patterns” book.  These are great lines and worth memorizing and mastering but memorizing these lines is like memorizing a whole sentence in a foreign language.  As an example: “Excuse me, where is the bathroom?” If you need a bathroom that sentence will be extremely useful BUT, it has limited use because you can’t use it in a different context or for different things.  It becomes useful when you start learning more words and combining them together.  Like pencil, road, bus, police station……now you can substitute all those words for bathroom and get way more use out of that one sentence.  What if you learn more words to use instead of “where”?  How about what,when and how……..now we have expanded our options even more!  I hope that illustrates the point, the more words you learn and the more you practice using them in different combinations the better you will be at communicating in that language.  The same holds true for the musical language.

Just like language has some rules that help you to communicate and make sense so does the musical line. Sure, you can just practice saying random French words in Paris and string them together to form a long sentence but people will not know what you are talking about.  It’s the same with the musical words. Through the practice of learning them and stringing them together you start to learn what works and what doesn’t.  What sounds good and what doesn’t.  There is learning the words but then there is learning how to use them together to communicate!

In the examples above, I can breakdown every line into it’s musical words or links as I like to call them in my Bebop books.  When I’m transcribing solos I try to do the same thing with what I’m transcribing.  When I practice I do the same with whatever new material I am working on……….

In your email you asked the question:

“Second question is about what you hear in your head versus what you play based on your mental breakdown of the music – you probably hear these notes now, but did you hear them as useful notes when you first learned  them?”

When I figured out how to create these smaller musical words and started doing it, they did sound good to me. I played them, I thought they sounded good, and then I would start to practice them.  The hard part isn’t finding the good sounding pieces or words but rather putting those pieces together.  That is what took me the most practice.

So when you hear me playing all of these mysterious fast lines and phrases I am not just making them up on the spot but rather putting the musical words together in different orders in the moment.  That’s why although it might have a similar sound it’s not the same exact line many times.

You also ask this question above which I think is important also:

I see jazz improvisation comments about chords.  I can play chord tones and arpeggios, but I don’t play chords on saxophone (I do that on guitar).  Therefore, I only use chords and key to open up the best candidate notes for the music.  Are your patterns (that do not sound like patterns) a way for you to play the chord?  If so, it sounds like much more than the chord.  On guitar I play 13ths and 11ths, but more than that tends to lose the gravity or real chord meaning.

Chords are the framework. The more you know them and hear them the better.  When I’m improvising I’m creating these lines but I always try to be mindful of the chord I am playing against.  If I am playing over E-7 I know how all 12 chromatic notes sound against E-7.  I know which ones sound good and which ones sound ok and which ones have a lot of tension and dissonance.  I know which notes are the resolution notes and sound the most consonant also.  All these things are super important.  Am I playing the chord?   No, not strictly speaking but……if you were to analyze my examples above you would see that I am outlining the chords with my downbeat notes.   Not all the time as you can see above but most of the time. These lines sound good  and hip because there is a balance of tension and release.

All this isn’t to say that I also don’t just improvise or imagine shapes or spontaneously play something that is new.  That happens all the time also and I get super excited when I discover new ideas while playing.  The elements I am specifically talking about above are related to the examples you asked about.  Ideally, for me, I like to have a healthy balance between using the language I know and venturing out on the edge and trying to create something new.

Hope this helps,    Steve

Filed Under: Jazz Improvisation Tagged With: Jazz Improvisation, jazz patterns, language, learning to improvise, phrases

Steve

About Steve

Steve Neff has been playing and teaching saxophone and jazz improvisation around the New England area for over 30 years. He is the author of many best selling jazz improvisation methods as well as founding the popular jazz video lesson site Neffmusic.com.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AvatarKeith M says

    August 24, 2015 at 4:19 pm

    Excellent article and response! This makes perfect sense. Thanks for sharing, Steve.

    Reply
  2. AvatarPeter says

    August 25, 2015 at 10:33 am

    Very thorough response, and very clearly explained!
    Thanks, Steve.

    Reply
  3. AvatarAnderson Kerigma says

    August 28, 2015 at 2:40 pm

    Dear Steve,

    I’m a Brazilian saxophone player… I’ve been playing the alto, tenor and soprano horns for many years, but not going seriously and deeply into the techniques to build up my chops. Although I’ve known your wonderful website for jazz classes years ago, only now I think I can manage my time to endure a long and consecutive journey for thoroughly learning the jazz “misteries” with you.

    As I join the website program, what should I do not to get lost amongst so many great lessons and information? Is there a recommendation in the lessons order?

    Thank you,

    Anderson
    Brasília, DF, BRAZIL

    Reply
    • SteveSteve says

      September 1, 2015 at 11:42 am

      Hi Anderson,
      Right now the site is setup like a library. You can browse all the lessons by category, read the descriptions and watch a video sample to get an idea what the lesson is about and the difficulty of it. After that, it is really up to you and what you decide you want to work on this month. I’m not sure what level you are at but if you have been playing for many years I don’t think the order of lessons is that important. What is important is that you pick a subject and topic that excites you. Focus on it and practice a lot. When you get to an intermediate level and have a lot of the basics down then it’s just a matter of what you want to focus on and master at that point. Hope that makes sense. Let me know if you have more questions, Steve

      Reply
  4. Avatarjoe nickerson says

    August 29, 2015 at 2:11 am

    great patient explanation Steve!

    Reply
  5. AvatarAnderson Kerigma says

    September 1, 2015 at 3:20 pm

    Thank you so much for your kind answer, Steve!

    Ok, I’ll try to browse every virtual corner here, to choose which lesson I shall primarily focus on. And yes, I let you know as soon as I find any difficulty or have any other question at all. 🙂

    Anderson

    Reply
  6. AvatarRaefbop says

    November 6, 2015 at 11:25 pm

    Bop is like weight lifting ; it takes time to get to the real heavy weights

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Cart

Subscribe to the Neffmusic Newsletter for the latest reviews and best deals delivered straight to your inbox every month. Join now and you will also receive my 40 Ultimate Michael Brecker Licks free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to


Thanks for joining!


NEFFMUSIC PRINTED BOOKS

Testimonials

Hello Steve,

I just want to say thank you so much for your unbelievable work, it is just mind opening, thanks for sharing it.

Wolfgang from Berlin

Wolfgang from Berlin
Thank you for the wealth of helpful lessons you’ve provided over the years.  I truly feel as though it has improved my playing more than the 4 years I spent at Berklee… and that’s not a slight on the school as I loved my experience there.
John
John
I just joined Neff Music last month. I can’t tell you how excited I’ve been to be able to pick back up on lessons. I’ve been in a rut and you got me out! I’ve especially appreciated the Lesson Path section. It was so clear I knew exactly where to jump in and start. Many many thanks!
Karin

Hello Steve,

I have not received my alto yet but have already gone through 14 lessons. I love your approach, style, knowledge and competence. I now regret so much to have stayed away from playing the sax for the past 45-50 years…(I am 65).  But It is never too late to get back to your first love. After 23 years in compuer sciences and 22 years in finances…I am now back to music for the rest of my life.

Doing some research on the net, I found this:

http://forum.saxontheweb.net/showthread.php?1… Read more

Claude
Hi Steve, I have been shedding your materials for quite a while now and I love them! They are extremely well organized and presented and there are tons of ’em! I really appreciate your methodical approach and find myself referring students to your resources often.  Thanks so much!  
Kenyon Carter
Thank you for all the educational information you provide.  I am a classically trained musician.  Professionally, I am a 4th and 5th grade band teacher.  I have played piano and sax for many years, but now I am starting to gig out more. I have always improvised by ear in the past. I have gotten by with my strong sense of pitch, rhythm and melodic contour. However, I want to go deeper. I want to play with a greater variety of melodic and rhythmic ideas to pull from.  I have studied to gain a … Read more
Ray
For anyone living in remote areas away from live jazz sax teachers, Neff is the way to go. In fact this is a great resource for anyone seriously interested in mastering the sax. I’ve never been disappointed in a lesson.
Oliver

Never really had lessons before just kinda worked things out on my own. Was in a rut but your lessons are really helpful in opening melodic possibilities. Ur an awesome resource to the saxophone community. Thanks for sharing. 

Anthony
I would like to say that in the last year my sax playing has progressed loads from your lessons. I have had a sax for about 20 years and dabbled with lessons from a few teachers and have learnt very little from them. As you have said in your lessons many teachers tell you to use the blues scale and leave it there, not even showing you the resolution points!!. I am now believing I can in time become a good improviser.
Thanks again,
Shane
Shane

Love your lessons!  I have been using your lesson packages for many months now, and am learning a lot.  It is so perfect for me with a very busy adult schedule and difficulty in taking jazz/improv music lessons from reputable instructors who live and hour or more away from me.

Lenore

I must say again how much I appreciate all your material. Including the video tutorials. It help keep me focused and knowing what to aim for. And your laid back teaching style appeals to me too. 

Thanks

P

P
Thank you so much for the great job you are doing to help further our jazz studies. Though I make my living as a repairer of musical instruments I am a student of jazz and have been fortunate enough to be involved with a big band and a combo for the last several years. As my children began to leave “the nest” I had decided to dedicate the next half of my life to a more serious study of the sax but I didn’t know exactly how I would go about doing this until a friend of mine turned me onto your si… Read more
Jon
Steve’s monthly lessons are entirely valuable. Without brow beating, he tells you all the stuff you deep down know you really should be working on, instead of just relying on the same old patterns. In spite of the fact that you’re taking a video lesson, Steve’s presentation is comfortable and “real”. In a little more than a year, he’s developed a library of lessons that seem to offer any player a lifetime’s worth of practice material. I’m just glad I stumbled upon it.… Read more
Grant
It is so refreshing to have a great player, who can provide lessons and examples in a manner which is understandable to most any enthusiastic saxophonist who is ready to improve. not just the, do this, do that, memorize this, memorize that… while all that is absolutely necessary, you go on to give reasons and examples to explain and validate why you have to do all of these things, the benefits, if you will… that is the key for me, you tell, explain, demonstrate, explain some more, you give perso… Read more
Cedric
I can see from your instructional videos that you are a fantastic teacher – one that can truly relate to all ages – humble yet very positive in approach – never coming across as superior and yet so totally capable of demonstrating the principles and techniques that you seek to impart to the students. I have gained so much confidence in my playing from “pouring over” time and again these invaluable lessons. Invaluable not only in musical content, but also in human interaction content. I am absolu… Read more
Ron

Hi Steve,

First, I want to thank you for all of your great lessons. They are like a “For Dummies” version of all the books on my shelf. The lessons break things down into manageable pieces, and give me the confidence that I’m practicing the right pieces. I’m starting to make progress.   Thank You,   Kim

Kim
I just started looking at my lessons and I have to say, dude you are awesome.  I ABSOLUTELY will learn from you!  I started the tenor about 1 ½ yrs ago and have since picked up an alto, and more recently a soprano.  I spend most of the time on the tenor, followed by soprano, and have only gotten to the alto a few times.  I think I’ll be sticking with tenor.  I’m having a great time and hope one day to play well enough to get regular gigs.  I’ve been playing keys for about 35 years (… Read more
Wil
I have found your videos and publications inspiring and your contribution to the world of saxophone playing is immense. Paul
Paul
Absolutely the best learning experience in my 40 years of playing.These books are awesome!!
Alfred LaBella
Hi Steve, I can’t express just how much I appreciate your teaching. My playing has improved so much over the past year since I have been studying and practicing with your lessons. It is possible to teach an old dog new tricks, these lessons are proof! Thanks, Michael Byington
Michael Byington
Steve- I joined your site this month and have downloaded 4 lessons and also purchased your new book and video on diatonic patterns. I just want to say I am very pleased with your approach and teaching techniques. I am getting back into playing after laying off for some time. The information you offer on your site is of great value and I am enjoying being a member. Thank you for what you are doing for the saxophone community.
Tony

I want to thank you again, because, not only are you an inspiration to listen to, you are a fine teacher!

I have been teaching sax and other winds for over 20 years, and you give me that “push” to give my students more!

Mark Peotter

Mark Peotter
Your lessons on playing the blues is so clear . I have been through many books on blues playing and not one of them explains as clear as your lessons . Most of them say “Play the same blues scale over all three chords of a 12 bar blues ” Its very misleading .     Thanks
Martin

After reading your story I will never feel quite right about complaining about any of my MINOR health issues!!    God bless Steve and I really hope that your health doesn’t stop you from fulfilling your calling.    These books have been such a help to open up my jazz vocabulary…   Thanks so much for sharing your story and for providing these great teaching tools…   John Leclerc   Saxophonist / composer/ EWI player and professional working musician of 35 years….

John Leclerc

Featured Video Lessons

  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $19.99
  • The Secret to Modern Outside Jazz Lines Lesson-Minor $9.99
  • Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson
    Rated 4.91 out of 5
    $9.99
  • The Secret to Altissimo (no one has ever told you about before) Lesson
    Rated 4.75 out of 5
    $9.99

Now over 600 video and audio lessons to choose from!
BECOME A MEMBER TODAY AND SAVE BIG ON EACH LESSON!

Free Lessons

  • Free Lesson on The New Ultimate II-V-I Primer-Major Keys
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering Altered Pentatonics
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering the Blues Scale Volume 1 & 2
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering the Dominant Bebop Scale and Language Book 1 & 2
  • Free Video Lesson on Approach Note Velocity Book

Recent reviews

  • Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Timothy
  • The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Ray Holland
  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Lloyd Whitty
  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Murray Middleman
  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Paul

Footer

Recent Comments

  • Steve on Drake FG (Freddie Gregory) Model Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Review
  • Jeff Coffin on Drake FG (Freddie Gregory) Model Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Review
  • Helen on 100 Must Know Jazz Tunes Consensus List
  • Joao Tavares on GetASax GS SLANT 7* Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Review
  • Steve on 10mFan Supernova Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece Review

Top rated products

  • The Style of Michael Brecker-Lesson 2
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • Developing Relative Pitch-Lesson 3
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • Mastering Major Diatonic Patterns (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $14.99
  • Mastering The Dominant Bebop Scale Lesson 1
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • In A Mellow Tone Dominant Bebop Solo Lesson
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99

Product tags

alto sax alto saxophone approach notes audio lesson bebop scale beginner beginner saxophone blues blues licks blues patterns blues scale blues scales diminished scale dominant chords ear training fundamentals II-V-I improvisation jazz improvisation jazz lines jazz patterns jazz sax jazz saxophone jazz standard jazz standards licks Mastering the Blues Scale Michael Brecker modern improv modern improvisation online lesson patterns playing outside practice habits reading music sax basics sax lessons saxophone scales smooth jazz steve neff tenor sax tenor saxophone video lesson video lessons
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • SUPPORT

Neffmusic © 2005–2023