• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Website of Steve Neff

  • BLOG
  • SHOP
  • MY ACCOUNT
  • RAVES
  • CONTACT

Search Neffmusic

You are here: Home / Reviews / Saxophone Stuff / The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Tenor Saxophone Reeds Review

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Tenor Saxophone Reeds Review

February 2, 2024 by Steve 6 Comments

Today, I am reviewing the new BSS Silver Box custom tenor saxophone reeds released by Jack Tyler at the Boston Sax Shop.  Jack has been my repairman for the last six years and always gives me the inside scoop on the newest Boston Sax Shop saxophone gear that is coming out.

Besides being a phenomenal repairman and craftsman, Jack is always up to some new saxophone related endeavor.  Whether it be straps, cases, ligatures, saxophone necks, reed cases, reeds, etc….. Jack always seems like he has a new project on the horizon……When I heard of these new BSS Silver Box custom tenor sax reeds he was developing, I had to try them!

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Saxophone Reeds

I have already reviewed the Boston Sax Shop BSS Black Box Custom Reeds which I totally love.  You can read that full review here: The Boston Sax Shop Black Box Custom Tenor Saxophone Reeds Review.

What I loved about the BSS Black Box custom reeds were how dark, warm, lush and round the tone sounded while using them.  When Jack told me that the Boston Sax shop was coming out with a BSS Silver Box custom reed that would be a brighter option for tenor sax players who dug the quality and thicker tip profile of the BSS Black Box custom reeds,  I was immediately interested in trying them out.

Here is the description of the Boston Sax Shop custom saxophone reeds from the Boston Sax Shop website:

“The Custom Reeds ‘Silver Label’ are a more brilliant counterpart to our original ‘Black Label’ saxophone reeds. Utilizing the thicker tip profile that makes Boston Sax Shop saxophone reeds so unique, I designed a new reed cut that evokes a more modern, radiant sound.

The ‘Silver Label’ reeds are an ideal option for players looking for additional projection and a little edge without sacrificing the evenness, consistency and resilience that Boston Sax Shop saxophone reeds have become famous for.  I couldn’t be prouder of the results.” -Jack Tyler (Owner and Designer)

The ‘Silver Label’ Custom saxophone reeds run with equivalent strength grading to our ‘Back Label’ Cut reeds.

Sold in boxes of 5 and 10 reeds

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Saxophone Reeds

As I wrote in the disclosure at the bottom of this review, I received 6 10 reed boxes of the new BSS Silver Box tenor saxophone reeds.  Two boxes of strength 2 1/2 reeds, two boxes of strength 3 reeds, and two boxes of strength 3 1/2 reeds.

Most saxophone players would probably only need one strength of tenor saxophone reed, but since I review so many saxophone mouthpieces, I find it beneficial to have a variety of reed sizes on hand so I can find the best saxophone reed for each mouthpiece I review.

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Saxophone Reeds

When I first tried the Boston Sax Shop Silver Box reeds, I played them next to their Black Box counterparts as I have been playing the BSS Black Box reeds for almost five year now (I also play Rigotti Gold reeds a lot as well).

At first, I had the impression that the BSS Silver Box reeds were slightly softer than the Black Box reeds but I think that impression came from the fact that the BSS Silver Box reeds had more of a brightness and buzz to them.  Usually, I associate that brightness and buzz to a softer reed but the more I played the new BSS Silver Box tenor saxophone reeds and compared them to the Black Box reeds, the more I realized that the strengths of both reeds were very close.

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Saxophone Reeds

As of the writing of this review, I have played through one complete box of the 2 1/2 reeds. One complete box of the 3 reeds and half a box of the 3 1/2 reeds.  The reeds seemed very consistent in strength and playability and of the 25 reeds I have tried so far 24 played great for me.  There was some slight variation in the strength of each reed but I considered this pretty normal and found each reed pretty close in strength to one another.

There was one odd reed that didn’t work for me and kept closing up on me in the higher register for some reason.  It felt like the tip area of the reed was too thin.  I couldn’t see anything visually that was wrong with it and was a bit surprised by the difficulty I had with it.  The other 24 reeds played great for me though. Still, 24 playable out of 25 reeds is a pretty good percentage in my book.

10 Boston Sax Shop Silver Box 3 1/2 Custom Saxophone Reeds

The BSS Silver Box tenor saxophone reeds were indeed brighter and they had a bit of a lively and resonant buzz to the tone compared to the BSS Black Box reeds.  Where the BSS Black Box custom reeds sound more focused and round with that warm dark core in the sound, the BSS Silver Box reeds had more brightness and edge in the tone.  This was even more apparent when I would put some more air through the mouthpiece.  The BSS Silver Box reeds just seemed to go into overdrive when pushed and the tone seemed to have much more of a bright energy compared to the BSS Black Box reeds.

On the sound clips below, I think you can hear the difference between the clips.  Especially in the higher range of the saxophone.  Those high notes with the BSS Silver Box just seemed to have more of a sparkle and bright buzz to them whereas the BSS Black Box reed high notes seemed more focused and less bright to my ears.

The Boston Sax Shop Black (left) and Silver Box (right) Custom Saxophone Reeds (the new Silver Box reeds have a line under the strength to differentiate them from the Black Box reeds

For the sound clips, I used an Early Babbitt hard rubber Otto Link 7* tenor saxophone mouthpiece that I have owned for about 20 years now.  I consider this mouthpiece to be a “middle of the road” tenor sax mouthpiece because it sits in the middle of that dark to bright tone spectrum for the tenor saxophone.

I tried to play many of the same lines, melodies and ideas for both sound clips although there are of course unintentional differences in the way I am playing between the clips.

I was most surprised by the differences between the beginning of both clips on the melody of “My One and Only Love” especially.  Even though I thought I played both clips very similarly, the Silver Box sound clip sounds more energetic and lively where as the Black Box clip sounds more refined, contained and laid back.  If there is a difference in the way I am playing, I believe that perhaps that brighter energy of the Silver Box reed influenced me subconsciously to play a bit more energetically and the more refined warmth of the Black Box reeds influenced me to play more to that more mellow and laid back style. It was certainly not intentional on my part.

On the other hand, if I didn’t play “My One and Only Love” differently, it might just be that brighter energy of the Silver Box reed that is making me hear the clip as more energetic.  Very interesting!  I’m curious what you think about this……..

Both reeds articulated well and handled the extremes of the saxophone range well.  I did find the altissimo range of the Silver Box reeds to lean towards that brighter and more aggressive type of altissimo tone you would use on a wailing sax solo over a pop or funk tune (it was easy to get that nice buzz and edge out of the tone that you need for those types of solos).  Of course,  I believe the Black Box reeds can do this as well but with a little less brightness, edge and buzz to those altissimo notes.

The Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Saxophone Reeds

The bottom line opinion from Steve Neff is that I love both the BSS Silver Box and BSS Black Box tenor saxophone reeds.  In my opinion, both reeds give me a different tone, response and vibe from each other.  I believe this difference is real and tangible and as much time as we spend messing with mouthpieces, ligatures and screws, the reed, in my opinion, is the most immediate and impactful source (next to the player themselves) for our sound, response and player feedback.

It really is a very personal choice but I would encourage you to at least try these great Boston Sax Shop line of reeds and decide for yourself what your favorite tenor saxophone reeds are that help you travel closer to that ideal sound you imagine in your mind’s ear.

If you are interested in the Boston Sax Shop custom saxophone reeds,  you can get them at these links Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom Tenor Saxophone Reeds and Boston Sax Shop Black Box Custom Tenor Saxophone Reeds. Neffmusic also gets a small commission from each sale using this link which helps support this website,  so thank you in advance if you use the link.

Thanks to Jack for sending me these great Boston Sax Shop Silver Box Custom tenor saxophone reeds to try.  Even now, weeks later, I am still just as excited to wet one of these reeds and put it on one of my mouthpieces.  I still haven’t tried these on the rest of my favorite tenor sax mouthpieces so I am super excited about how these reeds will perform with them as well.  Great job Jack!

If you try the Boston Sax Shop reeds, please come back and tell us what you think of them in the comment section below.    Steve

https://cdn.neffmusic.com/2024/SilverBSSHRLink.mp3

Early Babbitt 7* Hard Rubber Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece-Boston Sax Shop Silver Box 3 Reed

https://cdn.neffmusic.com/2024/BlackBSSHRLink.mp3

Early Babbitt 7* Hard Rubber Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece-Boston Sax Shop Black Box 3 Reed

*If you want to hear another great example that showcases the difference between the BSS Silver Box reeds and the BSS Black Box reeds, here is a video Dave Pollack made demonstrating the alto saxophone reeds.

Dave Pollack demonstrating the BSS Silver Box and BSS Black Box alto saxophone reeds side by side

Disclosure:  I received six 10 reed boxes (two boxes 2 1/2 reeds, two boxes 3 reeds, two boxes 3 1/2 reeds) of the Boston Sax Shop Silver Box custom reeds reviewed above for free in the hope that I would try them and perhaps review them on my blog.   I also receive a small commission when you purchase from the Boston Sax Shop website using the link above that helps to support this site. Regardless, I only review products that I believe will be good for other saxophone players to try also.    Steve

Filed Under: Saxophone Stuff Tagged With: black box, Boston Sax Shop, BSS, custom, reeds, review, saxophone reed, silver box

Steve

About Steve

Steve Neff has been playing and teaching saxophone and jazz improvisation around the New England area for over 30 years. He is the author of many best selling jazz improvisation methods as well as founding the popular jazz video lesson site Neffmusic.com.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. AvatarJack Tyler says

    February 2, 2024 at 10:58 am

    Thanks so much for checking them out Steve! Appreciate you 🙌🎷

    Reply
  2. AvatarBenjamin Hostetler says

    February 2, 2024 at 1:51 pm

    You gotta love Boston Sax Shop and the work Jack has done to design and create three great reeds (Black Label, Nexus, and Silver Label). For the most part, I agreed with your assessment but in regards to how you sounded, I think the extra cut of the Silver Label reeds brought an extra sparkle to the end of the notes that just stuck with me. I would be very curious to have you review the Nexus reeds as well and compare them to the Silver Label reeds.

    Reply
  3. Avatarmud says

    February 2, 2024 at 4:36 pm

    Thanks for posting this Steve, always love hearing your thoughts. Curious how you’d compare them to the Rigotti Gold reeds you use for your other reviews. (I think you play regular Rigotti Gold reeds, not the jazz cut, right?)

    I for one LOVE the BSS black box reeds. Phenomenal compared to anything else I’ve tried. Meanwhile, I’ve been back and forth on the Silver Box reeds, myself. I definitely think I need to give it a go again however.

    Reply
  4. AvatarDoug Lange says

    February 2, 2024 at 7:03 pm

    Thanks for this great review, since I have been curious about the differences between the Black Label and Silver Label reeds. Other manufacturers tend to go to the extremes between their reed cuts, so it’s good to know that Boston Sax Shop maintained the same characteristics as the Black Label and just dialed in a little more sparkle and brightness for the Silver Label reeds. I’m looking forward to trying them out!

    Reply
  5. AvatarJeffrey Newton says

    February 6, 2024 at 2:02 pm

    Both sound great! I hear a little more core in the black and a little more sheen in the silver, but these are “variations on a theme” and not a “horse of a different color.”

    I DO think equipment (any…) influences how we play. One commenter to a brief play-test horn clip (2 horns, same manuf., different metals) of mine said words to the effect of “we want to her the player, not the equipment.” I don’t think that’s *completely* possible, but hopefully the latter doesn’t overtake the former!

    Mic set-up, room acoustics, physical health, pay, pretty girl walking near the stage, etc., ALL influence playing…. Why should reeds be any different?

    Reply
  6. AvatarBob Rockwell says

    February 6, 2024 at 2:57 pm

    I thought you had better control on the Black Box reeds in the palm key register.
    Thanks for you work Steve!!!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Cart

Subscribe to the Neffmusic Newsletter for the latest reviews and best deals delivered straight to your inbox every month. Join now and you will also receive my 40 Ultimate Michael Brecker Licks free!

Select list(s) to subscribe to


Thanks for joining!


NEFFMUSIC PRINTED BOOKS

Testimonials

I am enjoying your style of teaching, and you’ve done a great job with the videos….good sound quality and well constructed lessons.  Balances the more guitaristic material found on the majority of guitar based programs.  Jazz vocab is what I’m all about at this point in the journey.  I especially dig the fact that you’ve studied with Bergonzi…helps me see his voluminous output in a more bite sized way.

Milton

Hello Steve,

I just want to say thank you so much for your unbelievable work, it is just mind opening, thanks for sharing it.

Wolfgang from Berlin

Wolfgang from Berlin
Two years later I began a search for a sax teacher and happened to come across Steve Neff when I was searching YouTube for sax teachers.  I went to neffmusic.com and was very impressed with the lessons Steve Neff was offering.  The concept of selecting lessons was an approach that I thought was unique and purchased a few lessons.  I liked the lessons so much that I signed-up for a 6 month package. I was very happy with all the lessons I selected.  I also purchased Steve’s book Mastering the B… Read more
Michael
I’ve been downloading your lessons for 4 months now (20 lesson) and I have noticed tremendous growth in my playing thus far! I’m so happy that I stumbled upon your site!
Bob

Thank You Steve. I think that I will be busy for years. Thank You for your great contribution to jazz music. Your books, more than teaching “how to play jazz”, actually teach “how to speak jazz”. I wish I found your methods years ago.  

Jean-Eric
Thank you for all the educational information you provide.  I am a classically trained musician.  Professionally, I am a 4th and 5th grade band teacher.  I have played piano and sax for many years, but now I am starting to gig out more. I have always improvised by ear in the past. I have gotten by with my strong sense of pitch, rhythm and melodic contour. However, I want to go deeper. I want to play with a greater variety of melodic and rhythmic ideas to pull from.  I have studied to gain a … Read more
Ray
I have found your videos and publications inspiring and your contribution to the world of saxophone playing is immense. Paul
Paul
I would like to say that in the last year my sax playing has progressed loads from your lessons. I have had a sax for about 20 years and dabbled with lessons from a few teachers and have learnt very little from them. As you have said in your lessons many teachers tell you to use the blues scale and leave it there, not even showing you the resolution points!!. I am now believing I can in time become a good improviser.
Thanks again,
Shane
Shane
I am a music book junkie and I have to say that your books are the most clear, user friendly, and helpful books I own.  They are my absolute favorites and I only wish I had them years ago.  I wouldn’t change a thing about the experience I had in acquiring my degree at Berklee, but my playing has perhaps grown more in the time I’ve spent buried in your books and lessons.  Keep up the great work!!! Thanks, John
John
Just wanted to send you a quick note to say thank you for being you, your playing, your website and your desire to help others. I’m a professional musician in the US Army and I’ve visited your website almost every day since discovering it a couple of months ago. Your lessons are profound and easy to use. I’ve purchased most of your PDF books and now am starting to delve more into the video and audio lessons.  Thank you for being a great resource!
James
Just to say thanks for your advice and lessons.  I’ve just read your amazing story.  I really appreciate what you do in regards to teaching.  I have bought a couple of your lessons and frankly they’re undersold.   I’ve learned much more with these two lessons than with 2 years of sax teachers.   Thanks so much………..
Mike
Thanks so much for putting all this great learning material out there. I don’t often have the time to take a lesson with a teacher, so the ability to download lessons is really invaluable. My playing has improved enormously (I think :)) – and the lessons are so varied there’s always something to be inspired by. Incredible value too!
Roger
Hey Steve, I’m a 22-year-old from Australia. I thought it would be worth saying. You’re an absolute legend. I can’t thank you enough. You have helped me rekindle my love for the saxophone and music as a whole. All the best for the future, your work doesn’t go unnoticed. PS. I am loving your devastating minor lines pdf.
Sapph
Hi Steve, I can’t express just how much I appreciate your teaching. My playing has improved so much over the past year since I have been studying and practicing with your lessons. It is possible to teach an old dog new tricks, these lessons are proof! Thanks, Michael Byington
Michael Byington

Steve, just a note to say thanks.

I’ve been playing a long time, but your material, laid out in such a thoughtful way, helps me to understand concepts in a new and deeper way.

You are a true gift to the jazz community.

60 lessons and going strong,

Kevin Ledbetter

Kevin Ledbetter
Steve really changed my way of practicing: I got a whole lot of new ideas for my playing the tenor.  His lessons are really helpful, give a lot stuff to practice and give clear answers to complicated stuff.  Steve has a lot of humor and I wish I had laughed so much in my former days with the horn.  All topics, from Blues to Approach note are dealt with clearness that wet ones appetite to play and practice that great ideas.
Uwe
I can see from your instructional videos that you are a fantastic teacher – one that can truly relate to all ages – humble yet very positive in approach – never coming across as superior and yet so totally capable of demonstrating the principles and techniques that you seek to impart to the students. I have gained so much confidence in my playing from “pouring over” time and again these invaluable lessons. Invaluable not only in musical content, but also in human interaction content. I am absolu… Read more
Ron
It is so refreshing to have a great player, who can provide lessons and examples in a manner which is understandable to most any enthusiastic saxophonist who is ready to improve. not just the, do this, do that, memorize this, memorize that… while all that is absolutely necessary, you go on to give reasons and examples to explain and validate why you have to do all of these things, the benefits, if you will… that is the key for me, you tell, explain, demonstrate, explain some more, you give perso… Read more
Cedric
First, I’m really excited about your materials! This site is a vast resource for any aspiring (and maybe already inspired) jazz musicians. I’m not a sax player, I play mandolin and fiddle, but have been learning jazz and playing weekly with a quintet for the past 6 months and have been struggling with all of the issues you get into in your lessons. I bought several books and lessons and plan to continue with some others as soon as I organize my practice routine. Thanks again for a great site … Read more
Tony Galfano
I want to say something about Steve Neff’s series of lessons, Beginner Jazz Improvisation. For a couple of years I tried many beginner lessons and my problem was that there was a gap between lessons that were fairly simple and ones that I was not quite ready for and my progress stalled out. That problem was solved with the series Beginner Jazz Improvisation. He guides you step by step along the way and builds a foundation for learning jazz and blues. He leaves no question about what to practice … Read more
Pete
I like so many other subscribers feel so encouraged by Steve’s learning techniques; you will enjoy reading the comments of praise others have left as you too will feel that you share a common view and path. I feel very lucky to have come across Neffmusic and that feeling will remain with you as you search through a treasure trove of learning materials on offer, you will quickly find the lessons that you are suited to. You will instantly recognize the unparalleled quality of Steve’s teaching … Read more
Stephen
I can’t say enough about my membership at Neff Music. Steve has taken the mystery out of playing the saxophone well and improvising both jazz and rock music. Like most struggling players I have a load of all sorts of books on my shelf just gathering dust. Books that I didn’t understand or know how to put to use…or just have the time to go threw them. Steve’s lessons really simplify things and he puts it in a way that I can understand. They inspire me to keep pushing and having him as my guide or… Read more
Ken
I am enjoying your style of teaching, and you’ve done a great job with the videos….good sound quality and well constructed lessons.  Balances the more guitaristic material found on the majority of guitar based programs.  Jazz vocab is what I’m all about at this point in the journey.   I especially dig the fact that you’ve studied with Bergonzi…helps me see his voluminous output in a more  bite sized way.
Milton
Steve’s monthly lessons are entirely valuable. Without brow beating, he tells you all the stuff you deep down know you really should be working on, instead of just relying on the same old patterns. In spite of the fact that you’re taking a video lesson, Steve’s presentation is comfortable and “real”. In a little more than a year, he’s developed a library of lessons that seem to offer any player a lifetime’s worth of practice material. I’m just glad I stumbled upon it.… Read more
Grant

Featured Video Lessons

  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book) Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $19.99 Original price was: $19.99.$14.99Current price is: $14.99.
  • The Secret to Modern Outside Jazz Lines Lesson-Minor The Secret to Modern Outside Jazz Lines Lesson-Minor $9.99
  • Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson
    Rated 4.91 out of 5
    $9.99
  • The Secret to Altissimo (no one has ever told you about before) Lesson The Secret to Altissimo (no one has ever told you about before) Lesson
    Rated 4.75 out of 5
    $9.99

Now over 600 video and audio lessons to choose from!

Free Lessons

  • Free Lesson on The New Ultimate II-V-I Primer-Major Keys
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering Altered Pentatonics
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering the Blues Scale Volume 1 & 2
  • Free Video Lesson on Mastering the Dominant Bebop Scale and Language Book 1 & 2
  • Free Video Lesson on Approach Note Velocity Book

Recent reviews

  • Bebop Scale-Altered Scale II-V-I Practice Lesson Bebop Scale-Altered Scale II-V-I Practice Lesson by Noah
  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book) Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book) by Andy
  • Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book) Mastering the Dominant Pentatonic Sound over a Blues (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Russ
  • Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson Creating Modern II-V-I Lines with Simple Pentatonics Lesson
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Timothy
  • The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson The Best Embouchure for Tone, Intonation and Endurance Lesson
    Rated 5 out of 5
    by Ray Holland

Footer

Recent Comments

  • Steve on Will the Real Michael Brecker’s Sax Mouthpiece Please Stand Up?
  • Perry on Will the Real Michael Brecker’s Sax Mouthpiece Please Stand Up?
  • Dominique on Otto Link Super Tone Master Florida V Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Review
  • Felipe on Drake Jerry Bergonzi Master Series Power Resonance 7* Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece Review
  • Steve on Ted Klum Focustone Standard Model Tenor Saxophone Mouthpiece

Top rated products

  • Mastering the Major Bebop Scale & Sound (Digital PDF Book) Mastering the Major Bebop Scale & Sound (Digital PDF Book)
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $14.99
  • Tune of the Week-Softly as a Morning Sunrise Lesson Tune of the Week-Softly as a Morning Sunrise Lesson
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • The Style of Dexter Gordon-Lady Bird Lesson 1 The Style of Dexter Gordon-Lady Bird Lesson 1
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • Tune of the Week-Days of Wine and Roses Lesson Tune of the Week-Days of Wine and Roses Lesson
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99
  • Tune of the Week-Invitation Tune of the Week-Invitation
    Rated 5.00 out of 5
    $9.99

Product tags

alto sax alto saxophone approach notes audio lesson bebop scale beginner beginner saxophone blues blues licks blues patterns blues scale blues scales diminished scale dominant chords ear training fundamentals II-V-I improvisation jazz improvisation jazz lines jazz patterns jazz sax jazz saxophone jazz standard jazz standards licks Mastering the Blues Scale Michael Brecker modern improv modern improvisation online lesson patterns playing outside practice habits reading music sax basics sax lessons saxophone scales smooth jazz steve neff tenor sax tenor saxophone video lesson video lessons
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • SUPPORT

Neffmusic © 2005–2025